High-Protein Brownie Cookie Skillet

If you’re torn between making brownies or cookies for dessert tonight, I’ve got the perfect solution for you… why not have both?

I’ve been experimenting with combining my love for fudgy brownies and skillet cookies, and the result is this incredible high-protein brownie cookie skillet. It’s the best of both worlds.

If you’re a chocolate fan, this is going to become one of your go-to dessert recipes because it is surprisingly simple to throw together. Each slice contains 12 grams of protein while keeping the calories at just 190. Not bad for a generous slice of fudgy brownie!

When you slice into this skillet, you’ll get the satisfying edges of a cookie with the fudgy center of a perfectly baked brownie. As a fan of the gooey center of a brownie, I can say that this fudgy texture does not disappoint.

How To Make a Brownie Cookie Skillet

To make this brownie cookie skillet, you’ll need a few key ingredients:

For the dry ingredients, we’re using a chocolate whey/casein blend protein powder, oat flour, a touch of almond flour, unsweetened cocoa powder, brown sugar substitute (or regular brown sugar), baking soda, and a pinch of salt.

For the wet ingredients, you’ll need creamy peanut butter, light butter or buttery spread (to reduce the calories a bit), and unsweetened applesauce.

And of course, we can’t forget the chocolate chips to give it those gorgeous melty pockets of chocolate!

The method matters almost as much as the ingredients in this recipe. One crucial technique I’ve discovered is adding the protein powder last.

Why? Protein powder absorbs a tremendous amount of moisture. By mixing all other ingredients first, then folding in the protein powder at the end, we create the perfect dough consistency. Check out this before and after when adding protein powder:

This might seem like a small detail, but it makes all the difference between a sticky, gooey mess and cookie dough that we can easily form with our hands.

The Baking Process

Many cookie recipes require chilling the dough before baking to achieve the right texture, but with this skillet we can skip that step. That means that all you have to do is mix the ingredients, put the dough in a skillet, and bake.

I use a 10″ cast-iron skillet to make my brownie cookie skillet, which I find works very well. This leads to a thin cookie, so if you prefer something thicker and more brownie-like, you can use a smaller skillet to achieve that result!

The skillet only needs about 12 minutes in the oven. Since all the ingredients are safe to eat raw, it’s perfectly fine to underbake it slightly for an even fudgier result, although 12 minutes leads to a wonderfully fudgy interior.

Even though this recipe comes together quickly and easily, there’s one small caveat: After baking, you absolutely must let the skillet cool for a full hour.

I know it’s tempting to dig in right away (believe me, I’ve been there), but this cooling time is essential. It allows the brownie cookie to set properly and develop that perfect fudgy texture.

If you cut into it too soon, you might think it’s undercooked when actually it just hasn’t set yet. Trust me, that hour wait is worth every minute!

Serving Suggestions

This brownie cookie skillet is delicious on its own, but for an extra-special treat, try topping a warm slice with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. The contrast between the cold ice cream and warm brownie cookie is insane.

This brownie cookie skillet would also be incredible to make ice cream sandwiches with, and that’s likely what I am going to try next. You can bake two of these in square pans, add some ice cream in the middle, and sandwich them together… yeah, I have to try that now.

Making It More “Brownie-Like”

If you’re firmly in the brownie camp and want something thicker, you have options! You can easily double the recipe for a thicker result, or simply use a smaller skillet.

I know that many people just want to take a spoon and dig right into a gooey brownie skillet, so you can definitely go that route.

Just keep in mind that if you want to make it thicker, you’ll need to bake it a bit longer. But remember – underbaking is not a problem with this recipe, so when in doubt, pull it out early for that fudgy center!

Storing Leftovers

I don’t blame you for wanting to eat the entire skillet, but if you decide to show a little self control, this brownie cookie stores very well. I find the texture holds up best when stored in the refrigerator, but room temperature works fine too. When stored at room temperature, it just tends to end up softer overall.

For a quick dessert later in the week, a brief 10-second spin in the microwave will bring back that fresh-from-the-oven texture and warmth.

This high-protein brownie cookie skillet has immediately become one of my favorite chocolatey desserts. But if this one doesn’t do it for you, I’ve got a bunch of other high-protein chocolate recipes here on my blog. Here are some of my favorites:

• 90-Calorie Protein Brownies with Crackly Tops
• Mouthwatering Oatmeal Brownies (With Protein)
• High-Protein Edible Brownie Batter
• Healthy Chocolate Crinkle Cookies (Protein Packed)
• High-Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter Spread
• Hot Chocolate Cookies with 10g Protein

Share The Love