Are donuts one of the best foods on the planet? Yes.
Are donuts also one of the hardest things to get right? Also yes.
Between messing with yeast, cutting them out, and deep-frying, there are just too many steps to making the perfect donut.
But these air fryer donut holes are going to change everything.
If you’re not familiar with donut holes, they are exactly what they sound like! When donuts are cut, it leaves behind a tiny little circle, which are then turned into these “donut holes.”
We’re going to make that process even easier. We’ll just mix up some dough, break off small pieces, and air fry them for 4 minutes. Yes, you heard that right: these air fryer donut holes take only 4 minutes to bake thanks to our trusty air fryer!
These donut holes have a crispy exterior with a soft, cakey interior. Plus, the nutrition is not too shabby, either.
With nearly half the calories of a Dunkin’ Munchkin and more than double the protein, these are a snack you can feel great about enjoying!
Update: The man Brad Bromlow gave this recipe a live review & taste-test in a YouTube video, so check that one out below:
How do you make air fryer donut holes?
These donut holes are so easy because they require absolutely no yeast, which means no waiting for them to rise!
All we have to do is mix up all of our ingredients, then break off small pieces to be our donut holes. Since these poof up while baking, we do not need to make them very large, either.
I don’t bother weighing them out to make them the same size, so I just eyeball the sizes. Sure, some of the donut holes will vary in size a little bit, but that rustic, imperfect look is even more appealing to me!
All in all, you should be able to get about 25 donut holes total out of this recipe. Depending on the air fryer you use, you’ll likely need to do these in two batches.
It’s important that you leave space between the donut holes so that they can fully heat all the way around. If you stuff too many in there (or stack them) they will fry up very unevenly.
These air fryer donut holes only require 4 minutes in the air fryer! We’re going to let them go for 2 minutes, then carefully flip them over to brown on all sides, then let them finish for the final 2 minutes.
After just 4 minutes, look how beautifully browned they are! If you wanted to eat them just like this, you absolutely can. These donut holes will have a great crisp on the outside and be incredibly soft and moist on the inside.
However, these are definitely better with some kind of coating. I tried half the recipe with a glaze and the other half with a powdered sugar coating. I must say, the powdered sugar really took these over the top.
I’ve always been a fan of powdered Munchkins from Dunkin’, and these taste like a spot-on recreation of those.
Needless to say, the entire batch did not last very long.
Why is the dough so sticky?
As people have re-created this recipe, a major criticism I’ve heard is that the dough is too sticky.
I didn’t experience that issue personally, but since it has come up a few times, it’s worth addressing.
I created a chocolate version of these donut holes, and in it, I tried out some different solutions. Check out the Chocolate Donut Holes recipe for more notes (and photos) on fixing the sticky dough, but here are some suggestions for ya:
- Be sure to use a protein powder that it a blend of whey & casein. Whey alone is going to be much stickier.
- If you must use 100% whey, add it as the very last ingredient.
- When you form the donut holes, put a little bit of flour in your hands to make rolling them much easier.
- If all else fails, throw the dough into the fridge for 30-60 minutes. When dough is cold, it becomes much less sticky!
Making a simple glaze
If you want to add a glaze to your donut holes, all you need to do is combine some powdered sugar and milk in a bowl, then toss the donut holes right in it!
To keep these sugar-free, I opted for a powdered sugar substitute. I always use Swerve, which I buy from Amazon, as I find it tastes identical to real-deal powdered sugar.
I added 75g of the powdered sugar substitute to a bowl with about 2 tbsp of milk. Whisk it up and viola, you have a glaze!
My glaze made enough to coat roughly half the recipe, so you may want to make a bit more depending on your preferences.
Depending on the type of milk you use, the thickness of your glaze will vary, so you may need to give your donut holes a double-coating.
This is what my glazed donut holes looked like after a single coating of the glaze because I added a bit too much milk to mine. But, it’s an easy fix!
After just a couple of minutes, the glaze will solidify enough for you to add the donut holes back to the bowl for a second coating of the glaze.
The glaze will solidify enough to enjoy after about 5-10 minutes, but you can also speed the process up by adding these to the fridge for a few minutes.
Preheating your air fryer is a must
I recently learned that you’re supposed to preheat your air fryer, and it blew my mind.
I always assumed that because air fryers heat up so quickly, that preheating is unneccesary. Boy, was I wrong!
I noticed when developing my Protein Churro Bites that my second batch fried up so much more than my first batch…
I just dismissed it, thinking “obviously the air fryer is hotter after using it once,” but it did not cross my mind that this is actually incredibly useful.
If you want the best crisp possible, preheat the air fryer! Since the beauty & magic of the air fryer is that we do not need oil, maximizing the crisp is the top priority, and preheating does that for us.
All you have to do is plug your air fryer in, turn it on at 370 degrees F, and prep the dough while it heats up. By the time you’re done, the air fryer will be hot and ready to go.
Trust me, it’s going to make a world of difference in any air fryer recipes you try.
No air fryer? No problem!
As the name Air Fryer Donut Holes implies, these come out best when using an air fryer. But, I know that not everybody has one of those! If you don’t, you can still make great donut holes in the oven.
For my Protein Cider Donut Recipe I used the oven, and the donuts came out great. For those, I baked them at 350 degrees F for about 10 minutes, and you should be able to get away with roughly the same amount of time here.
Put your donut holes on a baking sheet and just keep a close eye on them. Once they’re golden brown, they’ll be ready to go! I didn’t try it for myself so I can’t say for sure, but they’ll take anywhere from 5-10 minutes, so just keep watch.
If you try these air fryer donut holes for yourself and love them as much as I did, please leave a review below or come share your recreation with me on Instagram!
- 120g All-Purpose Flour
- 62g (2 Scoops) Vanilla Whey/Casein Protein Powder
- 42g Light Butter / Buttery Spread
- 100g Unsweetened Applesauce
- 1 Tsp Vanilla Extract
- 20g Granular Sugar Substitute
- 1 Tsp Baking Powder
- 1/4 Tsp Salt
- 75g Powdered Sugar Substitute
- 1-2 Tbsp Milk
- Preheat your air fryer at 370 degrees F while you prep the donut holes (about 10 minutes).
- In a large bowl, combine all of the dry ingredients for your donut holes (flour, protein powder, baking powder, sugar substitute, and salt). **If you are using a 100% whey protein, leave the protein powder out of this step and add it after step 3. More in the notes below.
- Add the vanilla extract, applesauce, and butter and mix it up with a silicone spatula until a dough forms.
- Once the air fryer is preheated, spray the basket with nonstick spray. I recommend using parchment paper made for the air fryer as well, but that is optional!
- Break off a small piece of dough, roll it in your palms, and then place it in the air fryer basket.
- Continue forming the donut holes and placing them in the air fryer, leaving enough space in between for them to heat evenly. Depending on the size of your air fryer, you may need to do two batches.
- Air fry the donut holes for 4 minutes total. After 2 minutes, use tongs to carefully flip each donut hole, then return to the air fryer for the remaining 2 minutes. Note: if your air fryer hasn't been fully preheated these may take a few minutes longer.
- Carefully remove from the air fryer and top/coat the donut holes however you'd like prior to serving.
For glaze coating: If you'd like to glaze the donut holes, add your powdered sugar to a large bowl and slowly stir in 1-2 tbsp of milk until it resembles a glaze. Add your donut holes to the bowl, then carefully remove the donut holes, allowing the excess glaze to run off. Place on a cooling rack to set.
For powdered sugar coating: Add powdered sugar to a large bowl and drop the donut holes right in when they come out (I didn't weigh out how much sugar I used). Since they are hot, the powdered sugar will stick no problem. Give them a toss until fully coated, then place on a cooling rack.
- IF USING 100% WHEY PROTEIN: I did a bunch of testing to make sure I could get this recipe right for you! While I highly recommend a whey/casein blend protein, whey definitely works. You just have to make a couple tiny changes:
- When you mix up your dry ingredients, leave the whey protein out completely. Add the wet ingredients and mix until you have a sticky batter. THEN mix in the whey protein powder to thicken the batter.
- The batter/dough is going to still be stickier than if you use a whey/casein blend. For me, I was still able to form the donut holes, but I needed to use a little trick. Either wet your fingers with cold water to be able to handle the sticky dough or flour your hands. You can try both methods and see what you prefer, but flour will work slightly better. Plus, we're going to add powdered sugar or a glaze, so it doesn't matter if there is some extra flour on these going into the air fryer.
- You'll need to let these cook for an extra minute, so 5 minutes total. I left these cook for 3 minutes, then flipped them over and let them finish for the final 2, and they worked out great.
- The "buttery spread" I use is Country Crock. Any butter spread, margarine, coconut oil, or regular butter will work great.
- If you made your glaze too thin, you can let the glazed donut holes set for a few minutes, then dip them back into the glaze.
- These donut holes are best served fresh, but will be great even for a few days. Store these in an airtight container at room temperature and enjoy throughout the week! Depending on how you coat these, they can also be reheated (although the glaze would melt, so be careful with that).
- Is your dough too sticky? See the notes above this recipe card on how to remedy that!
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Nutrition InformationYield 25 Serving Size 1 Donut Hole
Amount Per Serving Calories 35Total Fat 1gCarbohydrates 4gProtein 2.5g